Identity Management
- tags
- Security , Authentication , Authorization
Two parts
- Authentication (are you actually the person you say you are)
- Authorization (are you allowed to do what you are trying to do.)
SSO
Covering all bases for SSO
To cover all your bases, you need 2 identity providers. Any modern identity provider worth itself will also be able to sync back to an LDAP server to keep the two consistent.
- An LDAP server that’s preferably not exposed to the web
- An SSO identity provider that is exposed to the web.
Products
There are opensource and prioperty Products
| Name | Type | Remark | Released/Founded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keycloak | Open Source | Mature open-source IAM solution, Java-based, highly customizable. | 2014 |
| Authentik | Open Source | Modern open-source Identity Provider (IdP), focuses on flexibility and integrations. | ~2020 |
| Authelia | Open Source | Open-source authentication and authorization server, often paired with reverse proxies for SSO. | ~2019 |
| Ory Kratos | Open Source | API-first, headless identity & user management system, part of the Ory ecosystem. | 2016 |
| Casdoor | Open Source | UI-first open-source IAM/SSO platform supporting various protocols. | ~2020/2021 |
| Supertokens | Open Source / SaaS | Open-source authentication, often noted for session management, offers a hosted service too. | 2019 |
| Zitadel | Open Source / SaaS | Cloud-native open-source identity platform built in Go, focuses on multi-tenancy and B2B. | ~2019/2020 |
| Okta | SaaS (IDaaS) | Major enterprise-grade cloud Identity and Access Management (IAM) service. | 2009 (Founded) |
| Auth0 | SaaS (IDaaS) | Developer-focused identity platform, known for ease of implementation, acquired by Okta. | 2013 (Founded) |
| Clerk | SaaS (IDaaS) | Developer-focused authentication & user management, strong frontend component library (React, etc.). | ~2021 |
| Firebase Auth | BaaS Feature | Part of Google’s Firebase platform, provides backend authentication services for apps. | ~2016 |
| Supabase Auth | BaaS Feature | Authentication component of Supabase (open-source Firebase alternative), built on PostgreSQL. | ~2020 |
| AWS Cognito | Cloud Service | AWS identity service for web/mobile apps, offering user pools and federated identities. | 2014 |
Keycloak
- Open-source identity and access management by RedHat
- Managing users, roles, and permissions, as well as for implementing multi-factor authentication and social login.
- Supports authentication mechanisms such as OpenID Connect, OAuth 2.0, and SAML
- You also need to use their template and plugin system (so Java for Keycloak)
- Can’t use a different OAuth2 provider because well - you use Keycloak
- Needs to be selfhosted
- Keycloak with PostgreSQL on Kubernetes | Hacker News
Auth0
- Dedicated to providing its solution in the SaaS model.
- Owned by Okta now
Okta
- Identity SaaS product
Ory
- Has both selfhosted and SaaS based(Ory Network)
- Not super mature
Ory Kratos
- Released 2018
- Headless
- User registration, login, password reset, social sign in(Client side OAuth2), profile management, 2FA, and more
- Ory Kratos: Headless Authentication, Identity and User Management - Developer Friendly Blog
Ory Hydra
- OAuth/OIDC provider
- Have multiple apps that need a common sign-in method (SSO)
- 3rd parties to access your users data safely etc.
Oathkeeper
- 2017 : Access control for API endpoints
-
Can be run in 2 modes
-
Reverse Proxy Mode
- Acts as a gatekeeper, intercepting client traffic before upstream services.
- Applies access rules (authentication, authorization, mutation).
- Forwards allowed requests upstream.
- Rejects denied requests with an error.
- Functions as the Policy Enforcement Point (PEP).
-
Decision API Mode (Policy Decision Point)
- Exposes a decision API (e.g.,
/decisions) queried by an external proxy/gateway. - External proxy sends request details to Oathkeeper for evaluation.
- Oathkeeper evaluates rules and returns an allow/deny decision.
- External proxy enforces the decision (forwards or blocks).
- Oathkeeper acts as the Policy Decision Point (PDP).
- Allows integration with existing infrastructure (which acts as the PEP).
- Reverse Proxy: Caddy like usecase but does the auth for you
- Decision API:
- Exposes a decision API (e.g.,
-
Keto
- Authorization, define advanced permission rules (“Access Control Policies”)
- Permission management, roles, who is allowed to do what
Supertokens
- Ory has criticized these guys of using incorrect terms and specs etc.
Authentik
- Authentik is a full LDAP container reimplementation with many bell and whistles.
Authelia
- Authelia needs a LDAP or file backend with user credentials